Moby
Last Night: Remixed
Mute; 2008
Remix albums are a notoriously iffy musical proposition. Starting from the DJ’s and producers chosen to do the remixing, continuing on through the songs selected, and ending with the track arrangement, the whole scenario is a dubious one, laden with a host of unwanted expectations. In this reviewer’s mind, the real concern is whether or not an album needed to remixed in the first place – oh sure, you can take a track and pass it around to a few DJ friends and let them rework the song in question, but remixing an entire album is just inviting severe overkill into the equation. If the original artist is happy with his/her creation, why run the risk of poisoning those songs in the ears of your fans?
Well, Moby obviously possesses none of those fears, as he recently handpicked some hot DJ’s free range to toy with the standout tracks from his Spring 2008 release Last Night. The project was originally designed as a concept album chronicling a hypothetical night out on the town with his friends, but since Moby is no stranger to remixing the works of iconic acts himself, it seems that he concocted a follow-up record with those same club-going friends in mind. The result is Last Night: Remixed, which subjects the following songs to a wide variety of upbeat house-heavy treatments: “I Love To Move In Here,” “Ooh Yeah,” “Live For Tomorrow,” “I’m In Love,” “Disco Lies,” “Alice,” and “The Stars.”
The truly great cuts here include The Holy Ghost!’s version of “I Love To Move In Here,” Spencer & Hill’s take on “Disco Lies,” the Heavy Bass remix of “Alice” by Drop The Lime, and D.Ramirez’s Haunted Playground Remix of “Ooh Yeah,” because these DJ’s are able to take the source material and call it their own, while still honoring Moby’s intentions for the original. Also included as notable moments are “Live For Tomorrow” from Tocadisco and Mason’s Glowsticks Remix of “I’m In Love,” because, while they might be slightly formulaic, they are still fun and engaging. What threatens to sink the entire ship is the three-song selection that drops right in the middle of the album: Seamus Haji, General Midi, and AC Slater’s remixes of “I Love To Move In Here,” “Alice,” and “The Stars” (respectively) are rather boring, derivative, and much too safe. Sure, they might be bouncy, bubbly, and engaging for the non-discerning club-goer, but they do a grave disservice compared to the better remixes and to the original version.
In the end, the verdict for Last Night: Remixed is a hung jury; half the album is far superior to the other, creating a fractured listening experience. Each solid-to-excellent song has a bland-to-sad counterpart, leaving this reviewer to wonder whether an EP of the best material would have been preferable to an entire LP that comes across as merely average. Moreover, since the record was dubbed a “remix” album, would it not have been correct and/or proper to remix every song from Last Night in its original order? Maybe there’s a gap in this reviewer’s knowledge regarding DJ/club culture, but having purchased more than a few remix tracks of his favorite songs, quality is always preferable to quantity.